Categories
Blog Creativity

Color Kaleidoscope Shawl | MKAL Knitting Experience

This post may contain affiliate links; all opinions are my own. See Disclosures here.

My knitting motivation had been low this year and I was looking for something to jump start that spark again. It’s been a while since I participated in a Mystery Knit Along (MKAL), but I thought that might be exactly what I needed to get a boost of inspiration. Keep reading for my experience knitting the Color Kaleidoscope Shawl by Stephen West.

MKAL BACKGROUND

I knit the 2021 Westknits MKAL: Shawlography. I really enjoyed participating and keeping up with the weekly clues. The design was nice — a semicircular shawl with many unique stitch designs. I remember feeling super motivated and inspired each week. That’s the feeling I was hoping for this year.

I tried to participate in the 2022 MKAL: Twists & Turns, but I wasn’t loving the design and I wasn’t enjoying the experience. So after 2 clues, I just scrapped that project. I realized that I don’t like mysteries. I like to know what I’m going to be knitting. I like symmetry and that’s not guaranteed with a MKAL. And I like having better control of my colors — control that only comes from seeing the design first.

I told myself that MKALs weren’t for me. Then I saw the 2024 MKAL design, Go Go Dynamo, unfolding and I really wished I was participating. I did end up knitting that shawl after the fact, and I really enjoyed the design and construction.

This year I haven’t been knitting as much, and I’ve been looking for something to inspire and motivate me like I felt during the 2021 MKAL. So I decided that I would participate in the knit along this year!

HOW THE MKAL WORKS

The MKAL is a community knitting event where a shawl pattern is released in phases each week. The 2026 Westknits MKAL is the Color Kaleidoscope Shawl. The MKAL officially started on October 1st, but if you bought the pattern before then, you got a .pdf guide to help you plan your yarn.

COLOR PLANNING

I bought the Color Kaleidoscope Shawl pattern and it had all the information on yarn requirements and color tips — like how to incorporate speckled yarns in your palette. Color Kaleidoscope calls for 8 colors of fingering weight yarn in 50g skeins!

I was really excited to knit a shawl with 8 colors. My most favorite shawls have used a lot of colors and I was really looking forward to creating a palette for the mystery shawl.

the colors in the lauterbrunnen valley inspired my yarn picks

I decided to call back to a vacation we took to Switzerland to plan my 8 colors. I thought these colors were perfect for an autumn season knit, so I started searching for yarn to match these colors.

YARN

I’m really happy with the yarns I chose, and I think they definitely match the Switzerland vibe I was going for.

  • La Bien Aimee Little Kumo : Blanc
  • Cascade Heritage : 5682 White
  • Cascade Heritage : 5781 Clear Sky
  • Julie Asselin Fino : London
  • Spun Right Round Classic Sock : Treasured
  • Hedgehog Fibres Sock : Swamp Song
  • La Bien Aimee Little Kumo : The Shire
  • Spun Right Round Classic Sock : Hoof It
  • La Bien Aimee Sock : Kitsune
  • Spun Right Round Classic Sock : Chocolates

All my yarn obviously came in full skeins, so I planned on having leftovers since only 50g skeins were required. But I like all of these colors and can definitely see myself using them in other projects.

COLOR KALEIDOSCOPE

Color Assignments

I had my yarn, but I hadn’t wound it by the time the first clue was released. In the Clue 1 video, Stephen talks about color assignments and color pairings. I was starting to feel a little overwhelmed, but having the clue 1 schematic to color helped me make my assignments.

I used my swift and ball wider to wind my yarns into cakes. And after a couple days I was ready to make my color assignments:

  • A – Spun Right Round Classic Sock : Chocolates
  • B – Cascade Heritage : 5682 White
  • C – Hedgehog Fibres Sock : Swamp Song
  • D – Spun Right Round Classic Sock : Treasured
  • E – Spun Right Round Classic Sock : Hoof It
  • F – La Bien Aimee Sock : Kitsune
  • G – Julie Asselin Fino : London
  • H – Cascade Heritage : 5781 Clear Sky

Clue 1

Wedges

With my yarn colors assigned, I was really excited to get started on a new project. I used my US 4 needles with a 22″cable and cast on the first wedge with my color A (dark brown).

I had seen the clue 1 schematic and decided to modify the beginning wedges so that they were more symmetrical. So I knit two wedges per color, so that my wedge fan starts and ends with a color A.

I did this same kind of modification with my past Starflake Shawls, and I really like it for symmetry.

Triangles

I chose the two greens as my colors C and D because Stephen said these colors would play a bigger role in the next section. The greens were my favorite so I wanted them to have a prominent part in the shawl later.

The triangles were fun and easy and I enjoyed picking up stitches along the wedges to connect them. I wasn’t seeing much contrast between the two greens though and I regretted not using the Little Kumo held together with the darker green. But I thought it was fine and I would use the Little Kumo in the next green section.

Trapezoids & Wedges

I really liked continuing the geometric shapes in this next section. Using the red and orange really made the other colors pop. Throughout the shawl, I was weaving in the ends as I knit. But I didn’t want to trim them until after the shawl was complete and blocked.

This time I held Little Kumo together with the white and I think it added a nice texture. I was really enjoying how fast and easy each little shape was to knit.

This project reminded me of the rainbow Jigsaw Puzzle blanket that I made. That blanket was so huge and it was getting so heavy on my needles that I remember disliking modular knitting. But I was absolutely loving the Color Kaleidoscope shawl; I was enjoying each wedge.

Parallelograms & Wedges

I was happy to use my final two colors in this shawl and really see how things were coming together. This section was taking a bit of time but I was having fun.

I love how all of the shapes lined up perfectly; like cute little puzzle pieces. Then clue 2 was released and I started to feel like I was falling behind. I started this shawl a couple of days late, so I was already “behind” from the beginning. I just reminded myself that I was going at my own pace; it’s not a race.

I finished Clue 1 on Sunday, October 11th and I was so happy with how it looked. The colors all fanned out so beautifully and I really liked the symmetry in this design.

Clue 2

I was still working on clue 1 when the second clue was released, and I looked at the spoiler photos on Ravelry. There were two options to choose from in this clue — knit & slide or brioche. Normally I would choose brioche because it feels more challenging, but I preferred the look of the knit & slide. So before I even finished clue 1, I had decided on the knit & slide.

This clue 2 started by picking up stitches along the top of section 4, and then you work a knit/slip motif. I switched my needles over to a 37″ cable. It was nice to now be working longer rows and I felt like this section went by super fast.

I had made so much progress with the knit & slide section by the next day, I thought I might be able to finish this clue before the third clue was released! Even though I was embracing my pace, I really wanted to be on track with the clue releases each week.

I knit this section as written, with my color C (the darker green) and I held it together with Little Kumo to make it even darker. My two greens seemed different enough when I bought them, but when knit up, there wasn’t much contrast. The Little Kumo definitely helped keep C looking dark and I am happy with this section.

The final knit/slip border section was also really fast and I was able to finish Clue 2 on Wednesday, October 14th – just before the next clue was released!

Clue 3

To keep the full mystery for clue 3, I didn’t look at the YouTube video. I was excited to continue on with long rows of waves. I followed the pattern as written and I liked how everything was looking.

I’ve knit these types of waves in other shawls and whenever I knit a row with the yarn overs, it doesn’t look like they are lining up properly with the yarn overs from the rows below. But I’ve learned to just trust the pattern and it always ends up looking great.

During this clue, I relied on the web app by Freya’d Knot to help keep me on track to finish the clue before the next Thursday. But this clue seemed small and I finished the waves by Saturday.

It was nice to be ahead of pace, and I finished the slip stitch section easily. I started to think about what I would knit once I was done with this clue. The next section had little mounds and then a stripe which reminded me of the border of the Brioband Shawl. I was getting excited to see what the final border would look like. I finished clue 3 on Monday, October 19th.

Since I had so much time before the next clue release, I started work on my Aurora Cabin Shawl that had been in hibernation. I was feeling my knitting motivation come back and I was already thinking of what I would knit next.

Clue 4

I was really excited to see the final border for the Color Kaleidoscope shawl. I imagined a modular knitting callback to the wedges in Clue 1.

When I started the clue, I saw instructions for a lot of wedges and I thought my vision was coming true! But it ended up being a curvy border made of over 200 tiny wedges. I knit the first 5 wedges, and then the pattern wants you to change colors. I didn’t know if I was liking this color change so I went to the Ravelry discussion board to look up the spoiler images.

The wedges were not what I was envisioning and I didn’t love the recommended color changes. But I decided to knit the pattern as written except I chose to carry my color G (the gray) throughout, and then alternate between the blue and my darker green + Little Kumo held together.

Pattern Error

I was working through the wedges and I thought it was looking cool. But I noticed an error in the pattern. For the Wedges 9-15 repeat, it says to repeat Wedge 5 once more. But when I went back to wedge 5, the short row gaps are left “open” when you knit Row 1. So, I just closed the gaps as I knit the first row because surely that’s what was intended.

It was October 24th and I was knitting and watching my annual Lord of the Rings re-watch. Things were going great and I was making a lot of progress. I spread out my knitting to admire the border when I noticed that it looked like my wedges were not lining up properly. The wedges that should be on top of the mounds looked like were shifted over to the left. And there was a weird warping/pulling happening. Would this block out? Is this another situation like the yarn overs in the waves section and I just need to trust the pattern?

the top wedges were pulling and shifted to the left

It just didn’t look right. I counted my wedges and everything seemed good. I had been carrying my yarn in the icord and I thought I was keeping it nice and loose. Why was the pattern shifted??? Was it an illusion from my different color placements?

Errata Confirmed

So I went back to the Ravelry discussion board to see other people’s progress photos. Their borders were lining up perfectly. I started reading the posts and someone posted about that Wedge 5 error I had also found. Except the error wasn’t about needing to close the gaps on row 1; the error was that it should have been a Wedge 7 repeat instead.

Errata confirmed on Ravelry forum

Then I saw a post where Stephen confirmed it. Wedge 5 and Wedge 7 are opposite shapes. Wedge 5 has a THREE stitches joining the shawl, and Wedge 7 only has one. So every time I knit Wedges 9-15 repeat and I ended with a Wedge 5, I was shifting the border in error. :(((

I was so sad. I wish a pattern correction had been sent out instead of me having to search for answers after knitting through 140 wedges. 🙁

Making Changes

I obviously couldn’t let this mistake stay. But I was really annoyed and didn’t want to deal with knitting all those wedges again. I decided that I would just finish the shawl in a different way.

insert a lifeline and ripped all my work back

I had skipped brioche earlier in Clue 2, but I thought that would be a nice addition now. I took some US 2 needles on a 40″ cable and insert them into the final color E (orange) slip stitch row from clue 3. With my stitches secure, I pulled out the US 4 needles/cable and ripped out the mounds and wedge border.

Brioche Attempt
The brioche was nice, but I was worried it looked too dense

I adapted the brioche pattern from the Houses of Reykjavik shawl and used my color A as MC and color B as CC. I held the white color together with the fluffy Little Kumo for added dimension. The brioche was cool but it wasn’t looking quite right. I decided to rip it back and just knit the pattern as written.

Clue 4 – Take 2

I knit the clue 4 wedges as written but with only my colors A and B throughout. I liked the look of the two colors in my brioche so I thought it would be nice to use these colors with the wedges. My yarn was in full skeins so I wasn’t worried about running out of yarn.

Partway through the new wedges, I wasn’t sure I was loving the colors. I hoped that once I added the bonus border, it would balance out.

When I finished the wedges, I was happy with colors A and B getting brought back, but I was ready to add the extra border.

Bonus Border

I thought it would be really great to have a little rainbow stripe border. I brought in four other colors and knit three repeats of each color to create a cute earthy rainbow.

I really like how it looks and I think it does sort of soften the stark dark and light wedges. I did the final icord bind off in the dark brown color.

Washing + Blocking

I used a color catcher and some wool wash to wash my shawl. I let it soak for about 15 minutes in the cool water and then I gently squeezed the water out. Then I rolled the shawl in a towel to get the final excess water out and I laid it out on my blocking mats to dry.

I didn’t block it too aggressively. I used blocking pins along the top to give it a straight edge, and then I pinned the points to open them up a little. I wanted to see the yarn over details, but I didn’t eat the points to be pointy. So I pinned them down with the t-pins to kind of keep the points rounded.

FINAL THOUGHTS

my color kaleidoscope washed and blocked

I really enjoyed knitting this shawl. I am happy with my color choices and I like the finished shawl.

back of my shawl. I weaved in most of the ends as I knit

I was frustrated by the pattern error and wish the correction had been sent out when it was discovered. Eventually a corrected clue 4 was released, but it would have saved me a lot of extra effort if the errata was emailed as an update to the pattern when it was discovered instead of over a week later.

Aside from that, I’m happy I participated in the MKAL. I do feel like I am inspired to knit another project which was my goal.

Check out my Ravelry to see some of my other knitting projects!